An Italian wine list is the only document that can make a confident person order the second-cheapest bottle. It covers twenty regions, each of which thinks of itself as a country, and more native grapes than anyone has finished counting. In most years Italy makes more wine than anywhere else on earth, and it has never felt obliged to make it easy.
It gets easier with a map. Learn five regions and the grapes that belong to them, and most of a serious list opens up. This one is written from the cellar at ALBA, an Amalfi-inspired Italian restaurant in Knightsbridge with a Japanese menu and an omakase counter, where the list runs from the Alps to the volcano.
Why It Looks Hard
France names its wine by place and lets the grape follow. Italy does both at once, and then adds hundreds of grapes that grow nowhere else, each tied to a few valleys. So the same word on a label can be a grape in one region and a town in the next, and a wine named after its village may be made from something you have never heard of. Go by region and it sorts itself out.
Tuscany: Sangiovese
Tuscany has one great grape, Sangiovese, and it changes its name with the hills. In the centre it is Chianti Classico, which climbs through Riserva to Gran Selezione as the wines gain age and depth. Further south and warmer, in Montalcino, it becomes Brunello, bigger and longer-lived. In Montepulciano it is Vino Nobile. Then, on the coast at Bolgheri, Tuscany breaks its own rule. Cabernet Sauvignon, Merlot and Cabernet Franc went into the Super Tuscans of the 1960s and 70s, wines that ignored the regional laws and ended up setting the standard. The whites are quieter, though Vernaccia di San Gimignano is worth knowing.
Piedmont: Nebbiolo
In the far north-west, Nebbiolo makes Barolo and Barbaresco, the Italian reds that age the longest. They are pale in the glass and firm in the mouth, and they smell of roses and tar in a way nothing else does. They want patience, and they reward an older vintage. For a Tuesday, Piedmont grows Barbera, bright and generous, and Dolcetto, softer and ready sooner. The white truffle comes from the same hills, around the town of Alba, which is why Nebbiolo and truffle are spoken of in one breath.
The Veneto: Three Wines at Once
Around Venice and Verona, the Veneto does three quite different things. Prosecco, from the Glera grape, is the fizz of the aperitivo. Soave Classico, from Garganega grown on volcanic hills, is a white with real structure and a better wine than its reputation. Amarone della Valpolicella is the heavyweight. The red grapes are dried on racks before they are pressed, and the result is a wine of great weight and warmth, made for slow braises and winter evenings.
Campania and the South
Campania is the country behind the Amalfi Coast, and these are the wines that coast drinks. The whites lead. Greco di Tufo is mineral and firm, Falanghina is softer and more floral, and Fiano di Avellino is the most serious of the three. The red is Taurasi, from the Aglianico grape, sometimes called the Barolo of the south for its structure and its long life, and still undervalued. Further down, Puglia's Primitivo and Negroamaro make plush, sun-warmed reds for the table.
Sicily: The Volcano
Sicily used to sell its wine in bulk. Now it is one of the most interesting places in Italy, and Etna is most of the reason. On the slopes of the volcano, Nerello Mascalese makes Etna Rosso, a red often compared with Burgundy or Nebbiolo for its lightness and perfume. Carricante makes Etna Bianco, a white with a salty grip that suits seafood as well as anything in the country. Away from the mountain, Nero d'Avola is the island's generous red, and Frappato, served chilled, is its lightest.
Reading the List at ALBA
ALBA's wine cellar is built on these five. There is Chianti Classico through to Brunello and Bolgheri. There is Barolo and Barbaresco, with Barbera and Dolcetto beside them. There is Amarone, Soave and Prosecco from the Veneto, Greco di Tufo, Falanghina and Taurasi from Campania, and Etna Rosso, Etna Bianco and Nero d'Avola from Sicily. Around them sit a Champagne section, and Bordeaux and Burgundy for anyone who would rather drink French. The current wine list is on the site. The simplest way in is to name a region you like and ask what the list has from it. Book a table and put the map to use.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the main wine regions of Italy?
Every region makes wine. The five to know on a serious list are Tuscany, Piedmont, the Veneto, Campania and Sicily.
What is the difference between Chianti and Brunello?
Both are Sangiovese from Tuscany. Chianti Classico comes from the central hills and is brighter and ready sooner. Brunello comes from Montalcino, further south, and is bigger and longer-lived.
Which Italian wines go with seafood?
The whites of the coast: Greco di Tufo, Falanghina and Fiano from Campania, and Etna Bianco from Sicily. They have the salt and the acidity that fish, lemon and olive oil want.
